Greens should just shut up and listen by Jacinta Price
When elders from the communities of Kununurra, Wyndham and Ceduna travelled to Canberra last week with a video revealing the appalling violence on their streets, they delivered a strong message. Those streets are war zones of drug and alcohol-fuelled assaults and child abuse — and they want it to stop.
The video, supported by West Australian mining businessman Andrew Forrest, proves the desperate need for the cashless debit card system that quarantines 80 per cent of welfare recipients’ payments to limit access to alcohol, drugs and gambling.
These elders are crying out for the lives of the children being assaulted and abused. In one of these communities, 187 children are victims of sexual abuse with 36 men facing 300 charges, and a further 124 are suspects.
I know all too well the deep frustrations these Australian citizens feel as they are desperate to save their people from the crisis being played out day after day in their communities. They have long fought for our political leaders to recognise the need to take the tough — sometimes unpopular but necessary — steps to make meaningful change that will save the lives of Aboriginal children, women and men.
So why do large numbers of our media and our political leaders (including some indigenous ones) fail to respond to such clear evidence of assault, child abuse and violence at the hands of our own people but are prepared to call for a royal commission when the perpetrator is a white person in uniform or when institutionalised racism is perceived to be at play?
A television report on the horrendous treatment of juvenile inmates at Darwin’s Don Dale Youth Detention Centre swiftly sparked a royal commission. Yet footage of an Aboriginal man stomping on an Aboriginal woman and various other vicious acts — which in my view are far more shocking than that of the Don Dale footage — draws criticism by the Greens that the video was simply propaganda for the cashless welfare card. This is not propaganda; it is proof.
We hear regularly that we should be listening to Aboriginal people on the ground to understand the complexities of the problems and to encourage us to find solutions for our horrific circumstances. Well, here is a video created by Aboriginal leaders in conjunction with the wider community, including the police and a mayor, pleading for the implementation of a practical measure to help curb the purchase of alcohol and drugs so the lives of the most marginalised Australians may be improved. No, it is not a magic bullet, but it is a start towards improving the lives of Australian citizens in crisis.
Forrest has been criticised for telling the world that he has been approached by minors willing to sell sex. A 14-year-old I know who roams Alice Springs streets at night regularly witnesses children selling themselves to “old” Aboriginal men for alcohol and cigarettes. We pass such information on to the police, who already know it is happening, yet the authorities responsible for these children tells us they have seen no evidence of it. Just as there was a conspiracy of silence to deny the reality of frontier violence, now there seems to be a conspiracy of silence on the left to deny what is happening openly in our streets.
The evidence of deep crisis has never been so blatant. This trauma is inflicted on our people by substance abuse and violence fuelled by a taxpayer-funded disposable income. However, if a rich white man throws his support behind a group of frustrated and desperate indigenous leaders living with this trauma their plea simply is dismissed as perverse by the politically correct without offering any effective alternative solutions.
The Greens call Forrest paternalistic, yet WA Greens senator Rachel Siewert has the audacity to tell indigenous people how we should think, what our problems are and what we should be doing about it. Siewert and her party chose not to meet the elders who came all the way to Canberra from their remote communities to communicate the real problems.
The Greens reaction is nothing more than the racism of low expectations and egocentric virtue-signalling of those toeing the line of an ideology that is further compounding the crisis. If the video shocked you, good. It should; and what should follow is an appropriate response that recognises the human right of Aboriginal women, children and men to live in safety, free of drug and alcohol-driven violence and sexual abuse. Sacrificing whole generations to violence and abuse does not help the fight against racism. It reinforces it.
Jacinta Nampijinpa Price is an Alice Springs councillor and a research associate at the Centre for Independent Studies.
NAIRU — a harmful fairy tale
-
from Lars Syll The NAIRU story has always had a very clear policy
implication — attempts to promote full employment are doomed to fail since
governments an...
How Do We Fix the Collapse of Quality?
-
*Every product now has an "extended warranty" admission of the collapse of
quality and durability. *
*There's a great uplifting hope swirling around the p...
Steve Bellovin’s Retirement Talk
-
Steve Bellovin is retiring. Here’s his retirement talk, reflecting on his
career and what the cybersecurity field needs next.
No Meta Status Orgs
-
In health and medicine, we have many government agencies, and private
philanthropies, devoted to many specific medical conditions, and also to
studying and...
Reflections on Claims about Coral Cover (Part 1)
-
The Australian Institute of Marine Science (AIMS) put out a media release
earlier today claiming to have scientifically documented changes in coral
cover...
Trump’s dictatorship is a fait accompli
-
What can Americans do? What should Australia do? A few weeks ago, I drew up
a flowchart to estimate the probability that Trump would establish a
dictatorsh...
A Concept of a Plan … for the National Interest
-
This discussion highlights the structural challenges facing America’s
economic and political system, emphasizing how vested interests manipulate
markets,...
An Assay of Core vs Functional Intelligence Types
-
Not everyone excels in the same set of skills, and it is a mistake to
dismiss those whose abilities differ from our own as unfit for positions of
significa...
Week Notes 46-24
-
A full week, in which my cold stayed around taking away energy and focus.
Also a few urgent unexpected things to attend to. So I didn’t get around to
my ow...
ASKAP J1935+2148
-
MeerKAT is an amazing array of 64 radio telescopes in South Africa.
Astronomers want to expand this to the Square Kilometer Array, which will
actually cons...
ACM Paris Kanellakis Theory and Practice Award
-
(From Sergey Yekhanin; committee chair) Please nominate people to the
Kanellakis award – deadline is December 15.
https://awards.acm.org/kanellakis/nominat...
Copilot stopped talking to me
-
I was reading some arguments by Bettina Arndt recently about women
dominating the legal profession, especially in the Family Law sphere, so I
thought I wou...
The climate case of the century
-
by Lucas Bergkamp On the 12th of November, the Hague Court of Appeal ruled
in the “climate case of the century” that Milieudefensie (“FoE”) filed
against S...
Solar and batteries for generic use cases
-
A brief note on using solar and batteries as generic power sources. Over
the last few years of work at Terraform Industries, we’ve developed several
useful...
LET AMERICA BE AMERICA AGAIN – Langston Hughes
-
This poem, written in 1935 by black American jazz poet, communist, civil
rights activist, novelist and playwright, Langston Hughes (1901-1967), is
pertinen...
Letter to a Jewish voter in Pennsylvania
-
Important Announcement: I don’t in any way endorse voting for Jill Stein,
or any other third-party candidate. But if you are a Green Party supporter
who li...
I’m joining the Cornell faculty!
-
When I announced my intention to join Microsoft Research in 2008, my
friends set up a betting pool over how long I would “last” there. No one
thought that ...
Logo Overnight
-
Gary pointed me to a Mitchel Resnick paper (that probably has Brian
Silverman ideas in it) called Logo Overnight: computer programs that are
designed ...
Tips For Building and Deploying Robots
-
This post is not about research or developing software for robots. Instead
it is some tips on how to go about building robots for mass deployment and
how t...
Guest post: A letter to my son
-
Photo source: Heidi Gregory
*In our work in the La Trobe Science of Language and Reading (SOLAR) Lab,
my colleague Professor Tanya Serry and I have conta...
I am an Associate Dean for Academics
-
[image: A tweet by Associate Deans: “My favorite time of the year! Time to
cancel under-enrolled classes and reassign faculty to classes they aren’t
qualif...
Papert’s 8 Big Ideas (Lithuanian Translation)
-
Translation by Marius Narvilas Aštuonios didžiosios konstrukcionizmo
idÄ—jos Dr Seymour Papert 1999 Pirmoji idÄ—ja – mokytis darant. Visada
išmokstama ger...
On taking first steps into a new orientation
-
This is a follow-up to my post On improving a computing model. My posting
to this blog has slowed down a lot over the last few years. One reason for
that i...
Experts vs. Imitators
-
If you want the highest quality information, you have to speak to the best
people. The problem is many people claim to be experts, who really aren’t.
Saf...
GPT-4oReview
-
I asked GPT-4o to review this old technical report of mine. Speaking as a
sometime editor, I have had worse reviews from humans... Here is the resul...
Diary
-
For the full record. Arthur Dent deliberately set out to wreck this site
early in 2016 and considering it was on life support at the time this was
easily a...
Marble Maze Modules
-
Beyond the Marble: How Modular Mazes Build Skills and Spark Wonder Building
a marble maze is more than just a fun challenge—it’s a gateway to exploring
a w...
Return to 4th grade Code Club
-
One of my high school seniors wanted to do a service project teaching
coding to elementary students. He loved our field trip to the elementary
school that ...
Wellness: Bad Stress: Philosophy – Stoicism
-
In a previous post, I mentioned that I started researching wellness a few
months into the pandemic when I noticed my physical and mental health
declining. ...
No comments:
Post a Comment