Although this report falls short of recommending a Noel Pearson style full immersion Direct Instruction program it does thoroughly document the problem of education of indigenous Australians in remote communities and doesn't hesitate to blame the Government for it's failure in supporting separatist education philosophies and fudging the targets.
Indigenous Education 2012
Helen Hughes and Mark Hughes
The Centre for Independent Studies
from the Introduction:
We again give special attention
to the estimated 20,000 (of a total 170,000) Indigenous students enrolled in
Indigenous schools in ‘bush’ communities on Indigenous lands. These students have
been the principal victims of separatist education philosophies for Aborigines and
Torres Strait Islanders. In Indigenous schools, 90% literacy and numeracy failure
rates have been, and often still are, common. Another 40,000 Indigenous students
attend underperforming mainstream schools with above-average failure rates,
side by side with non-Indigenous students. However, the majority of Indigenous
students—more than 110,000—attend quality mainstream schools where they are
achieving national minimum literacy and numeracy standards; these students are
therefore not the subject of this report. Unwillingness to recognise these Indigenous
students’ high literacy and numeracy pass rates has fed low expectations of
Indigenous students’ abilities.
from the Executive Summary:
In 2008, the Council of Australian Governments (COAG) reduced the Indigenous education
target from fix the problem in four years to fix half the problem in 10 years. The first four year’s
NAPLAN results show that only Queensland and Western Australia have made significant
progress. All states and territories will struggle to reach the reduced target. On the education
ministers’ timetable, Indigenous children will not have the same education as non-Indigenous
children until 2028.
Most Indigenous Australians live and work in cities and towns. Their children—more than
110,000—attend mainstream schools and achieve minimum national literacy and numeracy
standards like non-Indigenous students. Indigenous students have the same intellectual capabilities
as non-Indigenous students. The education industry’s focus on ‘indigeneity’ is a politically driven
distraction. If indigeneity was the problem, the majority of Indigenous students would not be
School failure is the problem
Some 20,000 students attend Indigenous schools—those with 75% or more Indigenous
students. But only a handful of these schools are delivering effective literacy and numeracy.
Another 40,000 Indigenous students attend underperforming mainstream schools, side-by-side
with many more non-Indigenous students. Poor education delivered by these underperforming
schools is the principal cause of educational failure in Australia for both Indigenous and
Measuring literacy and numeracy 2008–12
The majority of Indigenous students pass NAPLAN tests, but there is also a significant poorly
performing minority. Queensland and Western Australia have made the most progress. But other
states and territories—and therefore Australia as a whole—are not on track to meet COAG targets.
Even where COAG targets will be met by 2018, Indigenous student failure rates will still be above
those of non-Indigenous students.
Causes of Indigenous education failure
Evidence shows that indigeneity, remoteness and a non-English speaking background are not the
reasons for high Indigenous failure rates. Non-performing schools are the principal cause of Indigenous
student failure. Welfare dependence, with entrenched low parental and student expectations, is a
major contributing factor.
COAG and Indigenous education
By adopting politically correct rhetoric instead of numeracy and literacy solutions, COAG—the peak
government body—contributes to the lack of progress.
About 200 Indigenous schools have the lowest NAPLAN results in Australia. A larger group of
mainstream schools in cities and towns deliver below average education to their Indigenous and nonIndigenous students. Under existing policies, only a handful of these schools are being reformed.
Indigenous education expenditure
Indigenous education is well funded. Much of the $360 million per year of ‘Indigenous specific’
education expenditure is, however, wasted on counterproductive ‘feel-good,’ ‘culturally appropriate’
programs that take time and attention from classroom instruction.
Trapped by illiteracy on Indigenous lands
The lack of education for the 70,000 Australians living on Indigenous lands is compounded by
a lack of job opportunities. In response, governments have created pretend jobs and training
programs that lead nowhere.
from section 11: Conclusions and Recommendations
In 2008, Australian governments dropped the target of educational equality for
Aboriginals and Torres Strait Islanders, replacing it with the soft target of ‘halving
the gap’ between Indigenous and non-Indigenous students by 2018.
NAPLAN results for the four years from 2008 to 2011 show only Queensland
and Western Australia making significant progress towards that target; a target
that will still see half the students in Indigenous schools in the Northern Territory,
Queensland, Western Australia, and South Australia fail reading and numeracy tests
Targets are easy to set and change when they get too hard. Governments and
education departments refuse to face the evidence that school ethos and classroom
instruction are at the heart of education problems. The failure to reform welfare
also contributes to high failure rates through low expectations and attendance rates.
Indigenous students have the same intellectual capabilities as non-Indigenous
students. The children of working Indigenous parents achieve the same NAPLAN
results as the children of non-Indigenous parents. The education industry’s focus
on indigeneity is a politically driven distraction. So is remoteness and English as
a second language. Non-Indigenous remote schools have high NAPLAN achievement
rates. Migrant children are taught English successfully.
About 200 Indigenous schools are at the extreme of failing Indigenous
performance. The Northern Territory’s more than 40 Homeland Learning Centres,
where students do not even have full-time qualified teachers, are at the bottom of
Australia’s more than 9,000 schools. Only 200 out of 2,000 students starting in
Indigenous schools in 2012 are on a path to mainstream education. Each year,
Indigenous schools add 2,000 non-literate and non-numerate teenagers to existing
welfare-dependent communities on Indigenous lands.
Underperforming mainstream schools in cities and towns betray both Indigenous
and non-Indigenous students. The NAPLAN performance of Aboriginal and Torres
Strait Islander students in these schools cannot be fixed without improving the
performance of the non-Aboriginal students sitting next to them.
Indigenous education is well funded. Most of the more than $300 million
Indigenous-specific expenditure, however, is spent on programs for which there is
no evidence of positive impact. These programs are counterproductive because they
take time and energy away from classroom teaching.
COAG Council of Australian Governments
NAPLAN National Assessment Plan—Literacy and Numeracy
A review of one of my favorite papers: Cognitive Apprenticeship (Collins, Brown, Newman) - I drew on Cognitive Apprenticeship a lot in my dissertation — so much so that Carl Berger asked me at my proposal, “Are you testing Cognitive Apprenticeshi...
2 hours ago